Legal Landmark Case – British Home Stores Ltd v Burchell: An Essential Milestone in Employment Law

Throughout our legal careers, we tend to notice that some cases just stay with us, not just throughout our training but because of their great legal significance to UK law and sometimes the necessity of their daily application.

Alternatively, most lawyers, and even some members of the public, will be able to recite a case plainly due to their utterly bizarre nature!

In our ‘Landmark Legal Case’ series, we will discuss a plethora of famous law cases in the UK that left an impression on us for one reason or another.

Introduction

Employment law plays a pivotal role in protecting the rights of workers and ensuring fair treatment in the workplace. Among the numerous cases that have shaped this field, British Home Stores (BHS) Ltd v Burchell stands out as a landmark ruling.

This case, heard in the UK Court of Appeal in 1978, established a crucial test for determining the fairness of an employer’s decision to dismiss an employee. Its impact has reverberated through subsequent employment law cases, setting a precedent that continues to influence legal proceedings today.

Background

In 1975, Mrs. Burchell worked as a shop assistant for BHS. Due to concerns about her performance, the company launched an investigation into her conduct. Following the investigation, BHS dismissed Mrs. Burchell, who subsequently filed an unfair dismissal claim.

The Case

The central question before the Court of Appeal was whether BHS had a valid reason for dismissing Mrs. Burchell and whether they had acted reasonably in doing so. The court sought to establish a test that could be used to determine the fairness of a dismissal.

The Burchell Test

Lord Denning, one of the greatest legal minds of the 20^th century, delivering the leading judgment, outlined a three-step test that would subsequently be known as the ‘Burchell test’.

This test has become a fundamental aspect of Employment Law in the UK and is the test involved in unfair dismissal. The Burchell test states that for a dismissal to be fair, an employer must have:

1. A genuine belief in the employee’s guilt – The employer must genuinely believe that the employee is guilty of the alleged misconduct or poor performance.
2. Reasonable grounds for that belief – The belief held by the employer must be based on reasonable grounds. This means that the employer should have conducted a reasonable investigation and gathered relevant evidence to support and substantiate their belief.
3. Acted reasonably in all circumstances – The employer’s decision to dismiss the employee must be a reasonable response to the alleged misconduct or poor performance. This is often referred to the test of reasonable responses – i.e. is the outcome one that a reasonable employer in all of the circumstances would take. This requires considering factors such as the seriousness of the offense, the employee’s length of service, and any mitigating circumstances.

Significance and Legacy

The Burchell test has had a lasting impact on employment law, providing a clear framework for evaluating the fairness of dismissals. Its establishment marked a shift towards a more objective and standardized approach to unfair dismissal claims.

The test has been widely adopted by courts, tribunals, and employment lawyers across England & Wales. It provides guidance to employers and employees alike, ensuring that dismissals are based on genuine and reasonable grounds. The Burchell test also serves as a valuable tool in avoiding arbitrary or unjust dismissals.

Furthermore, the case highlighted the importance of conducting fair investigations and gathering adequate evidence before reaching a decision to dismiss. Employers are now expected to carry out thorough and impartial investigations to support their decision-making process.

Conclusion

The BHS v Burchell case is a seminal judgment that has significantly influenced Employment Law in the UK. The establishment of the Burchell test provided a clear and structured approach for evaluating the fairness of dismissals.

By setting a precedent for genuine belief, reasonable grounds, and overall reasonableness, the case ensures that employees are afforded due process and protection against arbitrary or unjust dismissals.

Decades after the ruling, the Burchell test remains a vital tool in safeguarding the rights of workers and maintaining fairness in the workplace, and is as applicable today as it was in 1978.

Further reading

Unfair dismissal – Oakwood Solicitors

WHAT TO DO NEXT

Get in touch today for a no-obligation consultation. Choose one of the methods on the right-hand side of this page, or call us on 0113 200 9720 to find out how we can help you with your enquiry.